Recapping The Dead Files “Am I Crazy?” (Season 1 Episode 6) which aired 2011.
This week, we kick off Season 7 by revisiting “Am I Crazy?”, a case that asks a familiar question with an uncomfortable twist: is the homeowner losing her grip on reality, or uncovering a long-buried truth no one wanted exposed?
In Great Falls, Montana, Kelly believes she’s being contacted by the spirit of Valeria Gibson, a woman erased from the historical record and dismissed in death as “hysterical.”
Through dreams, intuition, and a growing pile of unsettling clues, Kelly uncovers a story that doesn’t match the official version, and medium Amy Allan corroborates that story.
As Steve Dischiavi digs for missing blueprints, vanished records, and suspicious inconsistencies, a pattern emerges: when women tell the truth, history has a habit of calling them unstable. But three women—Valeria, Kelly, and Amy—tell the same story across time.
She’s not crazy. She’s just not being believed.
So… is this a haunting? A cover-up? Or both?
So, grab your Nespresso, and join us where… The Activity Continues.
Content Warning:
We didn’t find anything we thought deserved a content warning, but we will use colorful language. I don’t see that changing.
Chapter Markers
00:00:00 Intro
00:00:36 Hello and Welcome!
00:08:05 Sidequest: Bougie Coffee
00:09:30 Overview
00:11:36 Segment 1 – The Set Up
00:15:02 Sidequest: Home Reno, Frugal Husbands, and Ghost Pets
00:36:11 Sidequest: Ableist Garlic
00:37:49 Ad Break
00:37:49 Segment 2 – Diggin’ Tru - The Investigation
00:47:17 Segment 3 – The Reveal
00:58:20 Research and Rabbit Holes
00:59:52 Sidequest: Your New Phrase “What the Munga?”
01:04:23 Valeria gets her spotlight
01:19:12 Next week
Episode links:
Nespresso pod maker: https://amzn.to/49Fpsng
Peet’s Coffee: https://amzn.to/49FkRBB
Paris Gibson: Man of Mystery: https://visitgreatfallsmontana.org/paris-gibson-man-mystery/
Great article, More Than Just the Founder’s Wife
https://www.greatfallshistorymuseum.org/blog/valeria-gibson-more-than-just-the-founders-wife
The Dead Files Official Podcast: https://pod.link/1642377102
Amazon links could generate a small commission to us at no cost to you.
The Activity Continues is a paranormal podcast where soul friends Amy and Megan chat about true crime, ghost stories, hauntings, dreams, and other paranormal stuff including the TV show, The Dead Files. Our recaps are full of recurring jokes about recurring tropes.
We also occasionally do interviews with people from the paranormal world, with the goal of learning from others. We think you’ll really benefit from the things these people have to say.
This episode was recorded on January 11, 2026, and released on January 22, 2026.
Disclaimer:
This podcast is in no way affiliated with Warner Brothers, HBOMax, the Travel Channel, Painless TV, or the TV show The Dead Files or any of its cast or crew. We’re just fans who love the show and want to build a community of like-minded people who would enjoy hanging out and discussing the episodes and similar content.
Credits:
Hosted by: Amy Lotsberg and Megan Simmons
Production, Artwork, and Editing: Amy Lotsberg at Collected Sounds Media, LLC. https://www.collectedsounds.com/
Theme song. “Ghost Story” and segment music by Cannelle
Background music: “Beyond the Stars” by Chris Collins
Engage!
Our website, https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/
Leave us a Voicemail: https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/voicemail/ (might be read on the show)
Newsletter sign-up: https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/newsletter
Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/theactivitycontinues
We’re on (almost) all the socials too @theactivitycontinues
SEND US YOUR PARANORMAL STORIES!
Email: theactivitycontinues@gmail.com (mailto:theactivitycontinues@gmail.com) and maybe it will be read on the show!
Voicemail: https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/voicemail/ to leave a message and maybe it will be played on the show!
BE OUR GUEST!
Are you a The Dead Files client, or a paranormal/spiritual professional, and are interested in being interviewed on our show? Let us know by filling out our guest form:
https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/guests/intake/
Affiliates/Sponsors
Please see our Store page for all the links for all our current affiliates. https://www.theactivitycontinues.com/store/
Thank you for listening, take care of yourselves. We’ll see you next time!
If you want to hear us early and ad-free EVERY week, become a Patron, join our Ghosty Fam and get bonus exclusive episodes! https://www.patreon.com/theactivitycontinues
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/the-activity-continues/exclusive-content
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
